byod assessment

BYOD in Assessment: Enhancing Learning with Personal Devices

Jacob BirnbaumOctober 31, 2024

The introduction of Bring Your Own Device (BYOD) policies by academic institutions has led to significant changes in education, particularly in the context of assessments. These policies permit students to bring and use their personal devices—such as laptops, tablets, or smartphones—during tests and exams, allowing them to take assessments in a familiar environment and potentially improving their performance. According to this source, 59% of companies have implemented BYOD policies by 2024. However, implementing BYOD for assessments also involves encountering challenges alongside the opportunities these policies provide.

Impact on Student Performance

Implementing BYOD in assessments can significantly improve student performance. Students benefit from reduced anxiety and a seamless experience when utilizing a device they are familiar with. For instance, a student accustomed to the accessibility features on their personal tablet, like text-to-speech or customized display settings, can perform better when these features are readily available during assessments.

Due to using a device they are familiar with, students may face fewer technical issues, such as navigating an unfamiliar operating system or using a non-preferred input method. For example, left-handed students might struggle with a right-handed mouse setup on school devices but would be comfortable using their own device configured to their preferences.

BYOD allows for a greater variety of resources to be utilized, such as educational applications and online materials, which can aid students’ problem-solving and critical thinking. In mathematics assessments, students might use graphing tools they’re proficient with, leading to deeper understanding and application of concepts. Furthermore, formative assessments can be conducted through engaging platforms that provide immediate feedback, aiding educators in tailoring instruction to meet individual students’ needs. Platforms like Kahoot! and Quizlet make learning interactive and can be seamlessly integrated into BYOD environments.

Security Concerns

Despite these advantages, BYOD presents potential security concerns, especially regarding the integrity of assessments. Students may access unauthorized resources, such as websites or applications, to find answers during an exam. For instance, a student might use messaging apps to communicate with peers or search engines to look up answers, compromising the fairness of the assessment.

To mitigate these concerns, strict guidelines and monitoring practices should be implemented by institutions and instructors. Secure testing environments are crucial, including both the physical location and the use of specific software that restricts access to unauthorized resources. Lockdown browsers like Respondus LockDown Browser or Safe Exam Browser can prevent students from navigating away from the test interface or opening other applications during the exam.

Creating a culture of academic integrity is of the utmost importance. Educators can discourage students from cheating by informing them of the ethical and academic implications of dishonest practices and emphasizing the importance of honest assessment. Investing in robust security measures, such as remote proctoring services and secure networks, can ensure the integrity of the assessment while still providing the benefits of BYOD. For non-educational exams such as certifications, the use of a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) or similar legal document is essential. For example, this can include language that the candidate will be taking the test on their own device, but will not attempt to cheat or steal content, or could face consequences such as being barred from taking the test again for one year.

Implementation Strategies

Successful implementation of BYOD requires careful planning and execution. Institutions should begin by providing clear guidelines that define acceptable use of personal devices and the responsibilities assigned to students. Specific facets include specifying which devices are permitted and what applications may be used during the assessment.

Training should be provided to staff to ensure they understand the permissions and restrictions and can provide a secure environment for students. Educators should be familiar with the technology used in assessments to troubleshoot issues and prevent security breaches. For example, teachers can be trained to use monitoring software that alerts them if a student tries to access unauthorized resources during an exam.

Considerations should also be given to those who do not own a personal device. Institutions might provide loaned devices or partner with organizations to supply devices, ensuring all students have equal access. For instance, a school could establish a device loan program where students can borrow laptops for the duration of the assessment.

Regular evaluations of the BYOD policy will allow for accommodations for new technologies and evolving student needs, ensuring the policy remains effective and beneficial for all involved parties.

Security Checklist for Implementing BYOD in Assessment

  1. Establish Clear Policies and Guidelines

    • Define acceptable devices and software.

    • Outline prohibited applications and websites.

    • Communicate consequences for policy violations.

  2. Use Secure Assessment Platforms

    • Implement lockdown browsers to prevent access to unauthorized resources.

    • Ensure compatibility with various devices and operating systems.

    • Regularly update platforms to address security vulnerabilities.

  3. Authenticate Student Identity

    • Require secure logins for assessment access.

    • Consider biometric verification for high-stakes exams.

  4. Monitor Assessment Environments

    • Utilize proctoring software to oversee student activity.

    • Train staff to recognize and address suspicious behaviors.

  5. Provide Technical Support

    • Offer assistance before and during assessments.

    • Prepare for common technical issues related to diverse devices.

  6. Promote Academic Integrity

    • Educate students on the importance of honest practices.

    • Include honor codes or integrity pledges in assessments.

  7. Ensure Equity of Access

    • Provide devices for students without personal ones.

    • Offer alternative assessment methods if necessary.

  8. Regularly Review and Update Security Measures

    • Stay informed about emerging security threats.

    • Adjust policies and technologies accordingly.

  9. Secure Network Infrastructure

    • Use encrypted networks during assessments.

    • Restrict network access to authorized users.

  10. Data Privacy Compliance

    • Adhere to laws and regulations regarding student data.

    • Ensure all platforms used comply with privacy standards.

Conclusion

The BYOD approach to assessments offers exciting opportunities to improve student performance but also introduces challenges related to security and implementation. In a world of constant technological innovation, institutions must balance leveraging technology to enhance learning while maintaining the integrity of assessments. Addressing these concerns through effective strategies can allow institutions to benefit from a more dynamic and responsive assessment environment provided by BYOD.

The following two tabs change content below.
Jacob Author Photo

Jacob Birnbaum

Jacob Birnbaum earned his Bachelor’s of Science in Marketing from Rowan University with a Minor in Japanese Studies. Jacob is an experienced writer and orator specializing in search engine optimization (SEO) and presentation of research findings. Jacob’s professional interests include conducting qualitative and quantitative research and analyses, as well as utilizing artificial intelligence for general data collection and analysis.
/by